Showing posts with label socialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label socialism. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

Capitalism, Socialism, Communism: formulating the problem



Introduction: I consider the main existing economic systems with the goal to reformulate the centuries-old economic debate as something like a problem in many-body physics (admittedly, very vaguely stated.)
Laissez-faire capitalism, or what is often called “wild capitalism”, is the most liberal, (i.e., free), economic system imaginable, whose description dates back to the works of Adam Smith. It is comprised of many small private units, firms and households, which try to maximize their profit or minimize their expenses. These units exchange goods, (i.e. interact), in a market in such a way that the whole system eventually achieves equilibrium, where the supply of goods from the firms equilibrates the demand for these goods by the households. The role of government is reduced to providing the medium for transactions (i.e., a market and the money) and ensuring that they are done in an honest way.
For someone, familiar with the basics of statistical physics and strongly correlated systems, the existence of such equilibrium in a many-body system does not seem impossible. Adam Smith, living in 18th century, was in a less fortunate situation. He had to introduce the concept of “the invisible hand” which has incurred much ridicule. “Capitalism is the astounding belief that the most wickedest of men will do the most wickedest of things for the greatest good of everyone.” - John Maynard Keynes.
Though hypothetically such an equilibrium state is possible, it still remains to be determined under which conditions it exists, whether it is achieved on realistic time-scales, and whether its parameters are always consistent with the demands of the general welfare as whether salaries in the labor market are sufficient to provide livelihood.
Laissez-faire capitalism is known to work in many situations but has also run into spectacular failures, most notably the Great Depression. It now exists only in developing capitalist countries (for example, in Russia), but still has many supporters, such as the Libertarian movement in the United States, represented by Ron Paul.
Communism is the total opposite of Capitalism. A communist government controls all production (i.e. the “firms”) and distributes goods to households. Ideally, even money is not needed under such a system.
In theory a centralized system is capable of producing and distributing required goods more efficiently than the many uncoordinated actors of laissez-faire capitalism. However, in practice it is known to be very slow in adjusting to the demands of households due to the length of the command chain (i.e., government bureaucracy), and its participants’ lack of personal interest in higher efficiency. It is also highly prone to abuse due to the excessive concentration of power in the hands of a small group of people, which tend to abuse this power either through deliberate evil doing or due to simple incompetence. The existing communist countries are examples of such abuses.
Communism also showed itself badly during the Great Depression: a famine in large and normally agriculturally profitable areas of Southern Russia and Ukraine took millions of lives in early 1930’s and even resulted in widespread cannibalism. It remains an open question whether “Holodomor” was the result of a deliberate genocidal policy by Stalin (as the Ukrainian government insists) or simply of his and his advisers’ economic incompetence. In either case it was exacerbated by the high centralization of power.
Regulated Capitalism is an attempt to salvage individual freedom, inherent in the Capitalist system, while limiting the possibility for its failure. It is achieved by establishing “fair rules of the game”: such as anti-monopoly laws when a greater number of competing firms are desirable and regulating natural monopolies where competition is unwelcome (e.g. water and electric supplies and public transportation are often cheaper and more efficient when provided on large scale).
Government may also play a greater role in carrying such functions as building public roads, enforcing law and order, and protecting the environment. While these functions are funded via taxation, it can be argued that taxpayers get fair value in exchange for what they pay. A firm that makes greater use of public roads than a private individual could pay proportionally more in taxes. A similar argument can be extended to funding the police and legal systems since businesses are more dependent on their protection than individuals.
Socialism attempts to improve general welfare by forcing the redistribution of wealth and by more heavily regulating business. I focus below on the economic shortcomings of socialism, but it is necessary to note that the main opposition to redistributionist policies is ideological. Although redistribution is often justified on the grounds of fairness, (i.e., general welfare) it is ultimately unfair from the point of view of individual rights, encoded in the laws of all the developed Western societies. Indeed, this redistribution is in fact a forceful confiscation of legally obtained private property. 
From the point of view of welfare, the main drawback of the socialist system is that the attempts to correct market outcomes often result in negative side effects. For example, rent control laws often give advantage to long-term tenants over those who are looking to move in: the latter are forced to pay a higher price for the same kind of property than the former. Similarly, labor unions drive higher benefits and salaries of employed workers (the price of labor) resulting in lower demand in the labor market, and therefore in higher unemployment than would exist in free market conditions.
While all the developed modern economies are to some extent socialist, their current state suggests that the socialist system is unstable. This is mainly due to the lack of a balancing mechanism that would restrict the growth of welfare benefits, which the majority inevitably awards to itself via the democratic process. This growth is usually funded via borrowing or increasing taxes, which are the same via the Ricardian equivalence, practices that cannot continue indefinitely. Eventually socialism either evolves into its logical extreme of Communism, the Marxist view, or faces the threat of economic instability and relapses back into a state with less welfare distribution, which what seems to be currently happening in Southern Europe and Ireland. In Israel such a turn took place as the result of hyperinflation in the 1980’s under the government of Shamir and Peres.
Formulating the problem
We thus face the problem of designing a social system which would be stable and generate satisfactory outcomes in terms of general welfare. This should include:
1. Formalizing the elementary units and the interactions in a laissez-faire capitalism system and finding under which conditions the system self-organizes and when, or whether, it can be stable.
2. Elucidating the basic mechanisms of instability in Socialist and Communist systems.
3. Determining the proper mixture of free competition, enforcing “fair rules of the game”, and wealth redistribution which would be stable, while providing a sufficient level of general welfare.

Friday, February 24, 2012

Collapse of socialism

Mario Draghi says outloud the thing that everyone knows, but no one has had courage to acknowledge:
"European Central Bank President Mario Draghi warned beleaguered euro-zone countries that there is no escape from tough austerity measures and that the Continent's traditional social contract is obsolete, as he waded into an increasingly divisive debate over how to tackle the region's fiscal and economic troubles.

In a wide-ranging interview with The Wall Street Journal at his downtown office here, Mr. Draghi reflected on how the region's travails were pushing Europe toward a closer union. He said Europe's vaunted social model—which places a premium on job security and generous safety nets—is "already gone," citing high youth unemployment; in Spain, it tops 50%. He urged overhauls to boost job creation for young people."
 

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Eurobonds and ECB intervention

I pointed recenly the strange logic of the advocates of creating eurobonds and the European Central Bank direct intervention - they keep having this discussion, despite its total irrelevance in view of the strong opposition from Germany and perhaps from some economically smaller contries that are still doing well (such as Austria, Finland, Netherlands.) (And Britain has just demonstrated that how one country's opposition can block any initiatives.)
Yet, they insist:
"The ECB has a strong rationale to act: to ensure the smooth transmission of monetary policy, to prevent a depression that would lead to deflation, and to avoid the breakup of the euro. Yet it has so far refused to do so, hiding behind a legal fig leaf.

Granted, Article 123 of the Lisbon Treaty prohibits the ECB from purchasing bonds directly from public bodies, but intervening in the secondary market is permitted. The ECB has long been doing so through its Securities Market Program. Where in the treaty does it say that extending the SMP is prohibited? Indeed, a credible open-ended commitment to contain interest-rate spreads would actually require fewer purchases than the ECB’s current limited and temporary program does."

and also:
"Eurozone leaders could also set out a roadmap towards Eurobonds, subject to strict conditionality, and tied to a credible mechanism for ensuring fiscal prudence. This would provide an additional incentive for governments that wish to qualify to introduce the necessary reforms, while reassuring the ECB and markets that governments remain committed to making the euro work."

Strangest of all is lecturing to Germans why their understanding of their own history is incorrect:
"Unfortunately, many Germans, notably at the Bundesbank, loathe the idea of central-bank intervention, because it conjures up memories of 1923, when the Reichsbank printed money to fund government borrowing, the resulting hyperinflation destroyed middle-class savings, and a decade later Hitler came to power. Yet Germans ought to remember that it was in fact the financial panic provoked by the collapse of the Austrian bank Creditanstalt, the resulting slump, and misjudgment by the German political establishment that cleared the Nazis’ path.

Far from precluding action, history justifies it. Besides, there is no reason to panic about inflation when monetary growth is low, bank credit is contracting, and people are hoarding money rather than spending it. Moreover, any ECB purchases could continue to be sterilized."

This might be true... but one also ought to remember that the above-mentioned "misjudgment by the German political establishment that cleared the Nazis’ path" was in fact the mijudgement by the Weimar Socialist Democrats, not so different from the socialists governments, whose misjudgement has brought about the European debt crisis.

Monday, December 12, 2011

Why socialism is so popular?

Von Mises Blog on socialism:
"One may wonder whether Sir William Harcourt was right when, more than 60 years ago, he proclaimed: We are all socialists now. But today governments, political parties, teachers and writers, militant antitheists as well as Christian theologians are almost unanimous in passionately rejecting the market economy and praising the alleged benefits of state omnipotence. The rising generation is brought up in an environment that is engrossed in socialist ideas.

The influence of the pro-socialist ideology comes to light in the way in which public opinion, almost without any exception, explains the reasons that induce people to join the socialist or communist parties. In dealing with domestic politics, one assumes that, "naturally and necessarily," those who are not rich favor the radical programs — planning, socialism, communism — while only the rich have reason to vote for the preservation of the market economy. This assumption takes for granted the fundamental socialist idea that the economic interests of the masses are hurt by the operation of capitalism for the sole benefit of the "exploiters" and that socialism will improve the common man's standard of living.

However, people do not ask for socialism because they know that socialism will improve their conditions, and they do not reject capitalism because they know that it is a system prejudicial to their interests. They are socialists because they believe that socialism will improve their conditions, and they hate capitalism because they believe that it harms them. They are socialists because they are blinded by envy and ignorance. They stubbornly refuse to study economics and spurn the economists' devastating critique of the socialist plans because, in their eyes, economics, being an abstract theory, is simply nonsense. They pretend to trust only in experience. But they no less stubbornly refuse to take cognizance of the undeniable facts of experience, viz., that the common man's standard of living is incomparably higher in capitalistic American than in the socialist paradise of the Soviets."